How We Verify Products
Every product on Truly American Made goes through a multi-step verification process before it appears on our site. We hold ourselves to the "all or virtually all" standard — the highest bar for Made in USA claims.
Last updated: April 2026
The Made in USA Standard
For a product to genuinely qualify as "Made in USA," it must be "all or virtually all" manufactured in the United States. This means:
- ✓Final assembly or processing takes place in the U.S.
- ✓All significant parts and processing are of U.S. origin
- ✓The product contains negligible (if any) foreign content
Products labeled "Assembled in USA" or "Designed in USA" do not meet this standard and are not listed on our site.
Our 5-Step Verification Process
Research Brand Manufacturing History
We investigate where the brand actually manufactures — not just where they're headquartered. We look for specific factory addresses, production facility photos, and employment records. Brands that name their factory city (like Lodge in South Pittsburg, TN or Channellock in Meadville, PA) score higher than brands with vague claims.
Verify at the Product Level
Many brands manufacture some products in the USA and others overseas. We verify each individual product, not just the brand. For example, not all New Balance shoes are made in America — only specific models from their US factories qualify. We check product-level claims, not just brand-level marketing.
Cross-Reference Multiple Sources
We don't rely on a single source. We cross-reference brand websites, retailer product listings, and independent reviews. A claim backed by multiple independent sources is far more reliable than a brand's self-declaration alone.
Calculate American Score
Each product receives an American Score from 0 to 100 based on the strength and quantity of evidence supporting its Made in USA claim. Products must score 70% or higher to be listed on our site. The score reflects how strong the manufacturing evidence is, not a quality rating of the product itself.
Ongoing Monitoring
Manufacturing can change. Brands sometimes move production overseas quietly. We periodically re-check our listings and remove products when we find evidence that production has moved. If you notice a product that's no longer made in the USA, we want to hear about it.
American Score Breakdown
Each product receives an American Score from 0 to 100 based on the evidence supporting its Made in USA claim. The score is computed algorithmically from six evidence signals, with an optional penalty for brands with known overseas production lines.
Brands with some product lines manufactured overseas receive a 10-point penalty. Only products with specific Made in USA evidence from those brands pass our threshold.
A brand that names a specific factory city (e.g. "South Pittsburg, TN") scores highest. State-level or regional claims score lower. Brands with no verifiable factory location receive minimal credit here.
The brand's own website explicitly claims their products are manufactured in the United States, with details about their facilities.
Brands with 20+ years of documented USA manufacturing history (LONG) score highest. Brands with a decade-plus record (ESTABLISHED) score moderate. Recent entrants (RECENT) score lowest, and must clear the bar via product-level evidence.
The strongest product-level signal: the listing describes manufacturing with a specific verb, city, and state — e.g. "Made in South Pittsburg, Tennessee" or "Hand-assembled in Brooklyn, NY". We accept 30+ manufacturing verbs (made, forged, crafted, milled, sewn, manufactured, assembled, hand-poured, etc.) and recognize both full state names and two-letter abbreviations.
When Amazon's own product metadata confirms "Country of origin: United States" via the Creators API, we award full external-verification points. A non-US country-of-origin tag auto-rejects the product regardless of every other signal.
The brand has a public website we can check — not an anonymous or untraceable seller.
Verification Tiers
Not every product we research makes it onto the site. Here's what each American Score tier means:
≥ 95%
Very High
Multiple independent sources including authoritative Amazon metadata
80–94%
High
Strong brand evidence plus product-level confirmation
70–79%
Brand-verified
Passes brand-level evidence; product-level evidence unconfirmed
40–69%
Needs Review
Insufficient evidence — hidden from the site
< 40%
Rejected
Claim could not be substantiated or contradictory evidence found
Why the new “Brand-verified” tier? Previously every verified product looked the same. Now, if we haven't confirmed Made-in-USA evidence at the specific product level (only at the brand level), we say so explicitly. Upgrading from “Brand-verified” to “High” requires either a Made-in-USA phrase in the product listing itself, or authoritative country-of-origin metadata from Amazon.
What We Don't List
- ✗Products that say "Designed in USA" or "Assembled in USA" but are manufactured overseas
- ✗Brands that have moved production overseas but still use American heritage branding
- ✗Products with unqualified claims that we cannot independently verify
- ✗Products scoring below 70% in our American Score assessment
American Score Distribution
Our American Scores reflect real variance — not every product scores the same. Here's how our catalog breaks down:
Based on 7,503 verified products currently listed.
Editorial Integrity — Removal Log
We hold ourselves accountable. When evidence shows a brand has moved production overseas or made misleading claims, we remove them. Transparency about what we reject is as important as what we list.
Recent removals and adjustments
- Products scoring below 70% are automatically hidden from the catalog
- Brands with significant overseas production (e.g., Carhartt, Woolrich) are flagged as Needs Review and excluded from listings
- Any community-reported issues are investigated within 7 days
By the Numbers
7,500+
Verified Products
1,280+
American Brands
15
Categories